Meine Fahrten
Freight Exchange Without Basic Fees - Which Platforms Are Truly Free
Free means three different things when it comes to freight exchanges, and the difference determines whether a platform is worth it for you. Truly fee-free in basic usage are ad and order exchanges like clickapoint, auftragsbank.de, transportbranche.de, box24, and frachtportal.net. There, you pay neither monthly nor per order, but you take care of the search, outreach, and credit checks yourself. Commission-based are tender portals like Shiply and Clicktrans, as well as matching platforms like MUVN Pro: a fee only applies when an order is actually completed. Subscription-based are the large freight exchanges, where the monthly fee runs independently of the order volume.
The honest calculation is therefore not "free versus paid," but fixed costs versus variable costs versus time investment. In a weak month, every commission model beats every subscription. In a strong month, it can be the other way around.
Which Freight Exchanges Can Be Used Without Basic Fees?
| Platform | Basic Fee | Fee per Order | What You Do Yourself |
|---|---|---|---|
| MUVN Pro | none | none | nothing. Payment is secured before the start, payout after delivery |
| clickapoint | none | none | Search, outreach, contract, credit check, collection |
| auftragsbank.de | none in basic usage | none | Maintain ads, handle inquiries yourself |
| transportbranche.de | none in basic usage | none | Review listings, check the other party yourself |
| box24.de | none for freight providers | none | Coordination and processing completely bilateral |
| frachtportal.net | none | none | Submit offers, handle processing yourself |
| Classifieds | none | none | everything, including sorting out dubious inquiries |
| Shiply, Clicktrans, uShip | none | Commission or brokerage fee | Calculate offers, compete in bidding |
| MUVN Pro | none | Service fee per mediated shipment | Provide ride or time slot, accept shipment |
| TIMOCOM, Trans.eu, Teleroute | monthly usage fee | usually none | Search, negotiation, processing |
What Does a Free Freight Exchange Really Cost You?
The price of a fee-free exchange is time and risk, and both can be quantified.
Time: If you go through two to three free exchanges daily, write inquiries, and follow up, you quickly reach five to ten hours per week. Set your own hourly rate for this, not zero. At a calculated rate of 30 euros, that's 150 to 300 euros per week in unpaid acquisition.
Risk: On an open exchange, the other party is not pre-checked. You take care of the credit check yourself, and if an invoice fails, you bear the loss alone. A single unpaid freight of 400 euros can consume several months' fees of a paid exchange.
Volume Fluctuation: Free exchanges have irregular volume. There are weeks with suitable orders and weeks without. As the sole source of orders, they are risky; as a supplement, they make sense.
When Does a Subscription Make Sense, and When Does a Commission?
The threshold can be calculated. Divide the monthly subscription fee by your average contribution margin per order. The result is the number of orders you need through this exchange monthly for the subscription to be worthwhile.
Example: If the monthly fee is 120 euros and your contribution margin is 80 euros per order, you need two orders per month just to break even. Anything below that is a loss. You should do this calculation with real numbers for two months before extending a subscription.
With the commission model, the calculation is unnecessary. If no order comes in, there are no costs. The downside: with very high volume, the total of the commissions can exceed the subscription fee.
Practical Rule of Thumb: Start with the free exchanges and a commission model. Calculate for two months, then decide whether to add a subscription. Not the other way around.
Are Freight Exchange Costs Subsidized?
The net expenses for using a freight exchange can be subsidized under the De-Minimis funding program. However, the contractual models of the providers differ significantly, and not every cost item is eligible for funding. Clarify this in advance with your tax advisor or the relevant funding agency before submitting a position. This text is not tax advice.
How Does the Model Work at MUVN Pro?
For drivers, MUVN Pro is free. No basic fee, no commission, no fee per order. What is agreed upon arrives with you.
You provide a ride that you are already doing or a time slot around your location. Suitable shipments will be suggested to you, the price range is set in advance, and you decide which orders you accept. There is no bidding process where you have to underbid others.
The most important point for calculation is still beside it: The amount is already collected from the client at the time of booking and paid out to you after confirmed delivery. No payment terms, no open receivables, no risk of default. On an open exchange, this is your biggest cost risk, and it does not appear in any fee table.
Additionally, every shipment through MUVN Protect is fundamentally insured, and higher coverage can be added per shipment. This also costs you nothing as a driver.
In summary, this means: At MUVN Pro, you incur neither fixed costs nor variable costs nor receivable defaults. The only investment is the ride you are already doing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Freight Exchange Is Completely Free?
clickapoint, auftragsbank.de, transportbranche.de, box24.de, and frachtportal.net can be used in basic usage without a basic fee and without order commission. Search, outreach, credit checks, and processing are entirely your responsibility.
Why Do Some Freight Exchanges Cost Money Monthly?
The fee finances the pre-check of participants, the volume, and the technical infrastructure. The argument is predictability: verified counterparties and daily available loads. The downside is that the fee also applies in months with low order volume.
How Many Orders Do I Need for a Subscription to Be Worthwhile?
Divide the monthly fee by your average contribution margin per order. With a fee of 120 euros and a contribution margin of 80 euros, it's two orders monthly just to cover costs. Calculate with your own numbers, not with example values.
Is a Free Freight Exchange Serious?
The platform itself is, but the individual participants are usually not pre-checked. Check the commercial register, VAT identification number, and reviews before the first ride, and work with new customers using partial prepayment or clearly documented payment terms.
Can I Use Multiple Free Exchanges in Parallel?
Yes, and this is also sensible with fee-free exchanges because the volume fluctuates there. The only investment is your time. With paid exchanges, usually only one is worthwhile until the volume supports it.